|
MISSISSIPPI
I. Definition of Gambling
1. Definition
"It is the character of the game, and not the skill or want of skill
of the player, which brings it into or excludes it from the prohibition of
the statute. The test to be applied in determining the character of the game
is whether the element of skill predominates over the element of chance."
MS Op. Att'y Gen. Allain, 1981 WL 40002 (October 26, 1981) (internal quotation
omitted).
But certain games played for money, such as poker, are explicitly declared
by statute to be gambling. MS ST § 75-76-5(k). In these situations, chance
and skill are irrelevant, as the game is already declared to be illegal gambling.
Slot machines are also defined as including both games of skill and games
of chance. MS ST § 75-76-5(ff). Consideration and payoff are the only
two elements required to find an illegal gaming machine; chance is not relevant
under the statute. Mississippi Gaming Com'n v. Henson, 800 So.2d 110,
113 (Miss. 2001).
"Lottery" is defined to include certain activities in which chance
predominates over skill. MS ST § 75-76-3(6)(b).
2. Exemptions
Prize, chance, and consideration are needed for a lottery. Mississippi
Gaming Com'n v. Treasured Arts, Inc., 699 So.2d 936, 938 (Miss. 1997).
Three-minute phone cards with scratch-off game sold for $2 did not constitute
a lottery where seller was paying long-distance company $.66 per minute for
minutes sold. Affidavit presented to court stating that usual long-distance
rate was $.45 was irrelevant. No consideration was being paid for the chance
to win. Fact that free game piece could be obtained through mail enforced
this conclusion. Mississippi Gaming Com'n v. Treasured Arts, Inc.,
699 So.2d 936, 938 (Miss. 1997).
Whether consideration is present is often a fact question. Ability to receive
a free game piece by mail is relevant, but not conclusive. 094 MS Op. Att'y
Gen. 725 (1994).
Poker tournaments, even though no consideration is paid to play, are illegal.
005 MS Op. Att'y Gen. 080 (2005). MS ST § 97-33-1 prevents the playing
of games. MS ST § 75-76-5(k) includes poker in the definition of game.
A game where $.05 is deposited and a trivia question is asked, with money
as a prize, is not gambling because skill, and not chance, is involved. Rouse
v. Sisson, 199 So. 777, 780 (Miss. 1941).
II. Definition of Bookmaking
MS ST § 75-76-55(1)(a) legalizes bookmaking only to the extent a license
for such is obtained. In the absence of such license, conducting a bookmaking
business is chargeable under the federal Illegal Gambling Business Act as
a violation of state law even though bookmaking is not specifically designated
as a crime. U.S. v. Stewart, 205 F.3d 840, 842 (5th Cir.
2000).
III. Specific Gaming Device Definitions
“Slot amusement machine or machine means any mechanical device or contrivance
which is operated, played, worked, manipulated, or used by inserting or depositing
any coin, slug, token, or thing of value, in which may be seen any picture
or heard any music, or wherein any game may be played, or any form of diversion
had.” MS ST § 27-27-3.
“Slot machine means any mechanical, electrical or other device, contrivance
or machine which, upon insertion of a coin, token or similar object, or upon
payment of any consideration, is available to play or operate, the play or
operation of which, whether by reason of the skill of the operator or application
of the element of chance, or both, may deliver or entitle the person playing
or operating the machine to receive cash, premiums, merchandise, tokens or
anything of value, whether the payoff is made automatically from the machine
or in any other manner.” MS ST § 75-76-5(ff).
“Gaming device means any mechanical, electromechanical or electronic
contrivance, component or machine used in connection with gaming or any game
which affects the result of a wager by determining win or loss. The term includes
a system for processing information which can alter the normal criteria of
random selection, which affects the operation of any game, or which determines
the outcome of a game. The term does not include a system or device which
affects a game solely by stopping its operation so that the outcome remains
undetermined . . . .” MS ST § 75-76-5.
Illegal slot machines under MS ST § 97-33-7 are those that "(1)
are operated by coin, token, or other consideration, and (2) dispense a product
with (3) the possibility of dispensing additional items at varying quantities."
Trainer v. State, 930 So.2d 373, 380 (Miss. 2006). There must be a
substantial element of chance. Rouse v. Sisson, 199 So. 777, 778 (Miss.
1941).
Cherry Master machine was gaming device because it rewarded additional playing
time, which is something of value (prize) for gambling purposes. Mississippi
Gaming Com'n v. Henson, 800 So.2d 110, 114-15 (Miss. 2001).
IV. Bucket Shop Laws
Commodities exchanges and boards of trade may be established. MS ST §
87-1-11. Contracts for future delivery of commodities may only be made through
such lawful boards. MS ST § 87-1-13. Transactions conducted on a legitimate
exchange or board are declared lawful. MS ST § 87-1-15. Cotton sold before
it is planted is not illegal gambling in futures when it is intended to be
delivered. Austin v. Montgomery, 336 So.2d 745, 749 (Miss. 1976).
Contracts for the sale of futures to be settled on public market quotations,
and not made on a lawful board of exchange, are void. MS ST § 87-1-19.
Contracts for future delivery are void where no actual intent to deliver is
present. Laird, Bissell & Meeds v. Capps, 80 So.2d 49, 49-50 (Miss.
1955). Bucket shops are places where transactions made void by MS ST §
87-1-19 are entered into; bucket shops are prohibited. MS ST § 87-1-21.
Violating these sections is a felony; the penalty is not more than 2 years
in jail and not more then $1000; but for a second offense, the penalty is
in the court's discretion.
Buying or selling commodities for future delivery, without intent to ever
deliver, is a misdemeanor. MS ST § 87-1-31. Dealing in futures contracts
is a misdemeanor punishable by $50 to $500 and up to 3 months in county. MS
ST § 87-1-33.
V. Prohibition of Games of Skill
1. Poker/Card Games Poker is specifically listed as a gambling game
under MS ST § 75-76-5(k). Betting on such games is prohibited by MS ST
§ 97-33-1.
2. Dice 3. Billiards 4. Bowling 5. Darts
VI. Express Exemptions
1. Social
2. Charity
MS ST §§ 97-33-51 through 97-33-81, 97-33-101 through 97-33-109,
and 97-33-201 through 97-33-203 constitute the Mississippi Charitable Bingo
Law. Charity bingo and raffles are not considered gambling games and are
exempt from the criminal statutes. MS ST § 97-33-51. All proceeds must
go to the charitable organization. Op. Att'y Gen. Evans (Jan. 18, 1991);
097 MS Op. Att'y Gen. 427 (1997).
The remaining provisions cover disposition of proceeds, Mississippi Gaming
Commission authority, definitions, licensing, applicant requirements and
investigations, special licenses for benefit of person or group, inspections,
session limits (8 per week), prize limitations ($7500 per session not including
pull-tabs), general conduct of games, records, reporting requirements, examination
of books and records by Gaming Commission and Tax Commission, penalties,
pull-tab requirements, equipment and supplies licensing, financial interests,
Charitable Bingo Fund, annual reports, Commission powers and duties, enforcement,
manufacturer/operator/distributor licensing, payments to commercial lessors,
and related matters.
Bingo is not a lottery, so the old (now repealed) constitutional lottery
prohibition did not invalidate this act. Knight v. State ex rel. Moore,
574 So.2d 662, 669 (Miss. 1990).
Class II bingo machines that look like slot machines, and where the player
plays against certain odds, rather than against other players for a common
pool, are not authorized under the charity bingo act. Op. Att'y Gen. Frilot
(March 19, 1992).
3. Chucky Cheese
MS ST §§ 27-27-3 et seq impose taxes on amusement machines.
Pinball machines which do not return to the operator or player thereof
anything but free additional games or plays shall not be deemed to be gambling
devices. MS ST § 97-33-7.
4. Commercial
See section X, regarding casino "cruises."
5. Lottery
A section of the Mississippi Constitution prohibited lotteries until the
repeal of that section in 1992. MS Const. art 4, § 98. Before the repeal,
the state construed "lottery" narrowly when it decided to implement
the Gaming Control Act. MS ST § 75-76-3(6).
Prize, chance, and consideration are needed for a lottery. Mississippi
Gaming Com'n v. Treasured Arts, Inc., 699 So.2d 936, 938 (Miss. 1997).
6. Horseracing & Other Pari-mutuel
Betting on shooting matches, yacht races, and horse races is illegal. MS
ST § 97-33-27. Fine up to $500.
VII. Specific Internet Prohibition
VIII. Gaming Crimes & Penalties for Unlawful Gaming
Municipalities have the power to prohibit bucket-shops, games, and gambling
houses; the municipalities can also set the punishment for such. MS ST §
21-19-19. They may also regulate slot machines and other gambling devices,
so long as those laws do not conflict with other state laws. MS ST §
21-19-33.
It is illegal to give stuff away in the form of a lottery to encourage voting.
MS ST § 23-15-561.
Antique slot machines (25 years old) are exempt from criminal statutes as
long as not used for gambling. MS ST § 27-27-12.
MS ST §§ 75-76-301 through 75-76-311 make the following illegal:
slugs, counterfeit chips, cheating, devices assist players in predicting outcomes
of games. Penalty for a first violation is not more than 2 years in jail,
and not more than $10,000. Subsequent violations are not more than 10 years
in jail, and not more than $10,000.
Any unlawful gambling place may be enjoined as a nuisance. MS ST § 95-3-25.
Slugs in coin-operated machines: Any person who shall operate slot
machine or other receptacle designed to receive coins in connection with the
sale of property or service, by means of a slug or any false coin or by any
means, method, trick or device whatsoever not lawfully authorized, is guilty
of a misdemeanor. Up to $100 and up to 30 days in jail. MS ST § 97-21-11.
Manufacturing such slugs or other devices is punishable by up to $500 and
up to six months in jail.
Vagrancy: A person who maintains himself mostly through gambling is
a vagrant. MS ST § 97-35-37.
Dog Fights: Wagering on, or encouraging wagering on, dog fights is
a felony. MS ST § 97-41-19.
One to three years in jail and $1000 to $5000.
RICO: Gambling offenses can be used as predicate acts under the State's
racketeering statute. MS ST § 97-43-3.
Betting: Playing any game for money or betting or wagering on any
game is punishable by up to $500. MS ST § 97-33-1. This section only
prohibits gambling. Op. Att'y Gen. Ringer (Aug. 19, 1991). This does not apply
to lawful gaming. Sporting events, like pool and foosball, have an element
of skill, so are not prohibited under this section; but betting on them is
still prohibited. Op. Att'y Gen. Ringer (Aug. 19, 1991). Wagering with public
money results in a $500 fine, 30 days in jail, and removal from office. MS
ST § 97-33-3. A winning gambler convicted must also pay over the amount
won as a fine. MS ST § 97-33-5.
"[G]ame or gambling game means any banking or percentage game played
with cards, with dice or with any mechanical, electromechanical or electronic
device or machine for money, property, checks, credit or any representative
of value, including, without limiting the generality of the foregoing, faro,
monte, roulette, keno, fan-tan, twenty-one, blackjack, seven-and-a-half, big
injun, klondike, craps, poker, chuck-a-luck (dai shu), wheel of fortune, chemin
de fer, baccarat, pai gow, beat the banker, panguingui, slot machine, or any
other game or device approved by the commission." MS ST § 75-76-5(k).
Possession of gambling devices: Possession of slot machine or gambling
devices is illegal. No property rights exists in such machines and they are
subject to confiscation. MS ST § 97-33-7.
Misdemeanor; up to $500 and up to 3 months jail. Upon second offense, prison
not less than 6 months, nor more than 2 years.
Since no property right exists in illegal machines, there is no Due Process
right to a hearing before it is confiscated and destroyed. Trainer v. State,
930 So.2d 373, 381-82 (Miss. 2006).
Gaming tables: Keeping or exhibiting any game or gaming table is a
crime. MS ST § 97-33-9. Fine of $25 to $2000 and up to 2 months in jail.
Club Gaming: An association of persons, commonly known as a "club,"
cannot have any interest in any gambling tables, banks, or games. MS ST §
97-33-11.
Misdemeanor; up to $500.
Owner Liability: Permitting an illegal game is prohibited. MS ST §
97-33-13. Fine from $100 to $2000.
Snitching: If a guest illegally gambles, and the keeper of the inn
or other place does not turn him in, the keeper shall be liable for $20 to
$100. MS ST § 97-33-15.
Forfeiture: Money and property used in connection with gaming is forfeit.
MS ST § 97-33-17. Resisting seizure of property is punishable by a $1500
fine and discretionary jail time. MS ST § 97-33-19.
Minors: Gambling with a minor or allowing one
to gamble is illegal. MS ST § 97-33-21. Minimum $300 and minimum 3 months
jail. The penalty is enhanced if you know the person is a minor. MS ST §
97-33-23.
Pools: Buying or selling chances in a pool is illegal. MS ST §
97-33-25.
Pay up to $500, and jail up to 90 days.
Horses: Betting on shooting matches, yacht races, and horse races
is illegal. MS ST § 97-33-27. Fine up to $500.
All gambling laws are remedial, not penal, and so are construed liberally
against the violator. MS ST § 97-33-29; U.S. v. Stewart, 205 F.3d
840, 843 (5th Cir. 2000).
Lotteries: Conducting a lottery is punishable by up to 5 years in
prison. MS ST § 97-33-31. Advertising a lottery is punishable by $25
to $100 and up to 3 months in jail. MS ST § 97-33-33. Editors and publishers
or newspapers are held liable for lottery advertisements in the papers. MS
ST § 97-33-35. Punishment is $100 to $1000 and 10 days to 3 months in
jail. Newsdealers distributing the papers are guilty of a misdemeanor punishable
by not less than $10 or not less than 10 days in jail or both. MS ST §
97-33-37. Selling lottery tickets is punishable by $25 to $100 or 10 to 60
days in jail. MS ST § 97-33-39. Buying a lottery ticket while in the
state is punishable by $5 to $25 and up to 10 days in jail. MS ST § 97-33-41.
An agent for a lottery faces a fine of $100 to $500 and 3 to 6 months in jail.
MS ST § 97-33-47.
Raffles: Holding a raffle is punishable by up to $20 and up to 1 month
in jail. MS ST § 97-33-49.
IX. Statute of Anne/ Recovery of Debts
"Contracts, judgments, securities, conveyances made, given, granted,
or executed, where the whole or any part of the consideration or foundation
thereof shall be for money, or any valuable thing won, lost, or bet at any
game or games, or on any horse-race, cock-fight, or at any other sport, amusement,
or pastime, or on any wager whatever, or for the reimbursing or repaying any
money knowingly lent or advanced for the purpose of such gaming or gambling,
or to be wagered on any game, play, horse-race, cock-fight, or on any sport,
amusement, pastime, or wager, shall be utterly void." MS ST § 87-1-1.
This does not apply to legal games, such as bingo that is regulated by statute.
Frank v. Dore, 635 So.2d 1369, 1374 (Miss. 1994). Any property, real
or personal, conveyed in connection with gambling, shall instead vest in the
wife and children of the conveyor/debtor. MS ST § 87-1-3.
The loser of any bet or wager, or his wife and children, may sue to recover
the property lost and actually paid over. MS ST § 87-1-5. This does not
apply to bets made in licensed gaming vessels. Neither does it apply to lawful
bingo games. Frank v. Dore, 635 So.2d 1369, 1374 (Miss. 1994).
Except as permitted in other sections, gaming debts not evidenced by a credit
instrument are void and unenforceable and do not give rise to any administrative
or civil cause of action. MS ST § 75-76-157. Casinos must report patron
payout disputes to the gaming commission; certain procedures must be followed.
MS ST § 75-76-159. But failure to follow the statute will not necessarily
result in recovery for the patron where the evidence shows that the patron
did not actually win. Mississippi Gaming Com'n v. Freeman, 747 So.2d
231, 244-45 (Miss. 1999). When a dispute is decided in favor of a patron,
the debt is enforceable and must be paid by the casino within 20 days. MS
ST § 75-76-165. Credit instruments are valid in a licensed casino. MS
ST § 75-76-175.
Violation of a patron’s Due Process rights may result when the casino
fails to follow the proper statutory steps for disputes. Grand Casino Biloxi
v. Hallmark, 823 So.2d 1185, 1187-88 (Miss. 2002).
Failure to follow administrative rules regarding disputes will deprive court
of ability to resolve matter (must exhaust administrative remedies). Cook
v. Mardi Gras Casino Corp., 697 So.2d 378, 380-81 (Miss. 1997).
Under the Mississippi Uniform Commercial Code, even a holder in due course
of an instrument (check) is subject to the maker’s defense of illegality.
MS ST § 75-3-305. Comment 1 to the section says that illegality is most
often a matter of gambling.
X. Lawful Commercial Casino Gaming
MS ST §§ 27-109-1 et seq regulate gaming on cruise ships
and vessels (which need not actually float). No inland gaming is authorized,
but permanent structures can be built to hold the “cruise ships.”
The result is “cruise ships” that look just like regular casino
buildings, but that must be located next to navigable waters. Regulatory power
is vested in the State Tax Commission and Mississippi Gaming Commission. The
sections also address Tax Commission rulemaking power, license qualifications,
vessel suitability, fees, penalties, and other matters.
Though one of the requirements is that the “vessels” have a minimum
draft of six feet, this does not prevent them from being located in an area
with less than six feet of water. Concerned Citizens to Protect the Isles
and Point, Inc. v. Mississippi Gaming Com'n, 735 So.2d 368, 375-76 (Miss.
1999). The six-foot draft requirement does not apply when the casino is permanent
(not really a vessel). MS ST §§ 27-109-1.
The Mississippi Gaming Control Act was created with the intention of licensing
and regulating gaming in Mississippi. MS ST § 75-76-1 et seq.
To this end, the Mississippi Gaming Commission is created. MS ST § 75-76-7.
The statutes in the Gaming Act regulate many aspects of the industry, including
appointment of Commission board members, meetings, Executive Director position,
creation of enforcement and investigation divisions, record maintenance, powers
and duties of the director, policy decisions, commission authority over charitable
gaming, investigations, commission rulemaking power, prohibition against teaching
gaming-related skills in public schools, excluded persons list, commission
control over internal fiscal affairs of casinos, financial reports, audits,
winnings reporting requirements, sales of securities in licenses, list of
acts requiring licensure, prohibited acts, transportation of gaming devices,
supplier requirements, tournament and contest registration, gaming license
qualifications, consequences of finding of unsuitability (not entitled to
profit), application form and content, steps in application approval process,
Tax Commission involvement, license issuance, fees, bonds, disclosed information
confidentiality, permission for race betting, license posting, fees, authority
of director to create list of approved gaming devices, physical presence requirement,
objects which can be used to represent money, investigations, emergency orders,
hearings, power to request court to hold person in contempt, court review
of agency decisions, disposition of funds, work permits, employee records,
full disclosure requirements, confidentiality of information, Attorney General
ability to restrain violations of the Gaming Act, penalties (civil and criminal),
age requirements, license fee computation, application and license fees, license
transfer, per-machine license fees, fee distribution, and other matters. MS
ST §§ 75-76-1 to 75-76-199.
MS ST §§ 75-76-199 et seq regulate the relationship between
business entities and casinos. Licenses can be issues to corporations and
other entities, but these statues contain many requirements concerning who
must be individually licensed and disclose information. Subsidiaries, foreign
companies, and penalties are among some of the many issues addressed. These
sections continue through MS ST § 75-76-265. MS ST §§ 75-76-267
through 75-76-313 are miscellaneous provisions containing penalties, foreign
gaming regulation, a certain cruise taxation exemption, a prohibition on officials
gaining pecuniary benefits, and criminal acts.
The Secretary of State is encourages to lease out as much state owned land
as practicable. Submerged land and tidelands may be leased to casinos. MS
ST § 29-1-107.
A company wishing to conduct legal gaming aboard a vessel or cruise ship
must file its intent to do so with the Mississippi Gaming Commission. Gaming
is then considered legal in the county (on vessels) unless within 30 days
a petition is signed by a set number of voters in the area. If such petition
is signed, a vote is then held in the county in which the gaming is desired
to determine if it will be permitted. MS ST § 19-3-79.
Mississippi imposes a 3% tax on gambling winnings that are taxable under
the Internal Revenue Code (above $1199). No deductible income tax credit is
given for paying this tax. MS ST § 27-7-901; MS ST § 27-7-903.
|